Politics
Germany Faces Questions Over €11 Billion in Defence-Related Borrowing
GERMANY — Germany is facing renewed political controversy over its defence spending after a new analysis claimed that around €11 billion of additional...
By Wavers Multimedia
The analysis by the Ifo Institute examined Germany’s use of a constitutional exemption that allowed the government to borrow beyond the normal limits of the country’s debt brake for defence and security-related spending. It found that spending covered by the exemption increased from €54.6 billion in 2024 to €72.2 billion in 2025, an increase of €17.6 billion.
However, the government took on €28.6 billion in additional borrowing under the exemption during 2025. Based on the difference between the additional borrowing and the increase in spending, the institute calculated that about €11 billion did not translate into additional defence and security expenditure.
The Ifo Institute described this as a 38.5% rate of funds that did not result in additional spending, raising questions about how Germany's new borrowing capacity was being used.
The findings have attracted attention because Chancellor Friedrich Merz's government has made strengthening Germany's military and increasing investment a central part of its fiscal policy. The government has also introduced major borrowing reforms and created a large off-budget infrastructure fund intended to support investment and economic growth.
Germany's Finance Ministry, however, has strongly rejected the Ifo analysis. The ministry described the findings as legally and methodologically flawed, arguing that the analysis does not correctly reflect the constitutional framework governing the special borrowing exemption.
According to the ministry's position, the relevant constitutional threshold is based on defence and security spending exceeding 1% of Germany's gross domestic product, rather than simply comparing spending with the previous year's level.
The ministry also argued that the constitutional rules do not require all spending covered by the exemption to represent entirely new or additional expenditure.
The Ifo Institute has defended the purpose of its analysis, saying it was not attempting to determine whether the government's spending complied with Germany's constitutional rules. Instead, it was examining whether the additional borrowing actually translated into additional expenditure.
The disagreement has emerged at a politically sensitive moment as Germany's governing coalition prepares to defend its proposed 2027 budget in parliament.
Opposition politicians have seized on the analysis to question the government's handling of the country's expanded borrowing powers. Critics argue that if large amounts of new debt can be used without producing corresponding increases in defence spending, the government needs to provide greater transparency about where the money is going.
The issue has also become connected to broader concerns over Germany's public finances. The government has sought to use increased borrowing to strengthen the military while simultaneously supporting infrastructure investment and economic recovery.
The debate therefore goes beyond the €11 billion figure itself. At its centre is a larger question over whether Germany's new fiscal rules are delivering the additional defence investment that lawmakers and the public were promised when the borrowing restrictions were changed.
The Finance Ministry maintains that the Ifo calculation uses the wrong benchmark, while the institute insists that its assessment is focused specifically on whether additional borrowing produced additional spending.
With Germany facing pressure to strengthen its military capabilities and increase investment while maintaining fiscal credibility, the dispute is likely to remain an important issue as lawmakers consider the country's next budget.